Current:Home > MarketsVirginia teacher shot by 6-year-old can proceed with $40 million lawsuit, judge rules -AdvancementTrade
Virginia teacher shot by 6-year-old can proceed with $40 million lawsuit, judge rules
View
Date:2025-04-12 17:42:50
NEWPORT NEWS, Va. (AP) — A teacher who was shot by her 6-year-old student in Virginia can press forward with her $40 million against a school system over claims of negligence by school administrators, a judge ruled Friday.
The surprise decision by Newport News Circuit Court Judge Matthew Hoffman means that Abby Zwerner could get much more than just workers compensation for the serious injuries caused by January’s classroom shooting.
Lawyers for Newport News Public Schools had tried to block the lawsuit, arguing that Zwerner was eligible only for workers compensation. It provides up to nearly 10 years pay and lifetime medical care for injuries.
The former first-grade teacher was hospitalized for nearly two weeks and endured multiple surgeries after a bullet struck her hand and chest. Zwerner alleges that administrators ignored multiple warnings the boy had a gun that day and had routinely dismissed ongoing concerns about his troubling behavior.
Some legal experts expected Zwerner’s lawsuit to fail under Virginia’s uncommonly strict workers compensation law. That’s because it covers workplace assaults and allegations of negligence against employers. Lawsuits that might move forward in other states often falter in the Commonwealth.
A tentative trial date for Zwerner’s lawsuit is scheduled for January 2025.
The classroom shooting by a first-grader revived a national dialogue about gun violence and roiled this military shipbuilding cit y near the Chesapeake Bay.
In early January, the 6-year-old pulled out his mother’s handgun and shot Zwerner as she sat at a reading table. She rushed the rest her students into the hallway before collapsing in the school’s office.
Zwerner sued in April, alleging school officials ignored multiple warnings that the boy had a gun and was in a violent mood.
Police have said the shooting was intentional. Zwerner claims school officials knew the boy “had a history of random violence” at school and home, including when he “choked” his kindergarten teacher.
The school board filed motions to block the litigation, arguing that workplace assaults and allegations of negligence fall under Virginia’s workers compensation law.
Zwerner’s attorneys countered that workers’ compensation doesn’t apply because a first-grade teacher would never anticipate getting shot: “It was not an actual risk of her job.”
“Her job involved teaching six-year-old children, not exposing herself to criminal assault whenever she went to work,” Zwerner’s lawyers wrote in a brief to the court.
J. H. Verkerke, a University of Virginia law professor, previously told The Associated Press that Zwerner’s attorneys faced an uphill battle under the state’s strict workers compensation law. He said they needed to prove the shooting was unrelated to Zwerner’s job, even though she was shot in her classroom.
Their challenge was “to somehow make out that it’s personal,” Verkerke said.
Zwerner’s attorneys argued the boy’s “violence was random and aimed at everyone, both in and out of school.”
He “asserted that he was angry that people were ‘picking on’ his friend, a motivation that had nothing to do with (Zwerner),” her lawyers wrote without further elaboration. “His motivation was a personal one.”
The school board disagreed, writing that the shooting cannot be personal because 6-year-olds lack the capacity to form intent according to Virginia law.
The lawyers also questioned how the shooting could be anything but work-related.
“Everything about this incident arises from (Zwerner’s) employment as a teacher,” the school board argues. “There is no allegation — nor could any such allegation be credibly made — that (Zwerner) had any personal relationship with (the student).”
Workers’ compensation laws were deemed a grand bargain in the 20th century between injured workers and employers, Verkerke said. Workers lost the ability to sue in most cases, protecting employers from enormous payouts. But people who were injured gained much easier access to compensation — lost pay and medical coverage — without having to prove fault.
veryGood! (6)
Related
- Who's hosting 'Saturday Night Live' tonight? Musical guest, how to watch Dec. 14 episode
- Clemson University imposes 4-year suspension on fraternity for ‘chemical burn’ ritual, other hazing
- Far-right activist Ammon Bundy loses defamation case and faces millions of dollars in fines
- Report: Kentucky crime statistics undercounted 2022 homicides in the state’s most populous county
- 'Most Whopper
- Former pastor charged in 1975 murder of Gretchen Harrington, 8, who was walking to church
- Wendy's unveils new cold brew coffee drink based on its signature Frosty
- Gilgo Beach murders: Police finish search at suspect's Long Island home
- Could Bill Belichick, Robert Kraft reunite? Maybe in Pro Football Hall of Fame's 2026 class
- Sheryl Lee Ralph opens up about when her son was shot: 'I collapsed and dropped the phone'
Ranking
- A Mississippi company is sentenced for mislabeling cheap seafood as premium local fish
- Thomas Haden Church talks 'rumors' of another Tobey Maguire 'Spider-Man,' cameo possibility
- Gas pipeline explodes near interstate in rural Virginia, no injuries reported
- Adam Rich, former 'Eight Is Enough' child star, dies at 54
- Travis Hunter, the 2
- 3 found dead in car at North Carolina gas station are identified as Marines stationed nearby
- Raven-Symoné Reveals She Has Psychic Visions Like That's So Raven Character
- NFL Star Matthew Stafford's Wife Kelly Slams Click Bait Reports Claiming She Has Cancer
Recommendation
Costco membership growth 'robust,' even amid fee increase: What to know about earnings release
Flooding closes part of Seattle-Tacoma International Airport concourse
Whitney Houston's voice is the best part of 'I Wanna Dance With Somebody'
Anyone who used Facebook in the last 16 years can now get settlement money. Here's how.
'Survivor' 47 finale, part one recap: 2 players were sent home. Who's left in the game?
Mega Millions jackpot grows to $820M ahead of Tuesday's drawing
Venice Film Festival unveils A-list lineup with ‘Priscilla,’ ‘Ferrari,’ ‘Maestro’ amid strikes
Twitter is now X. Here's what that means.